To ensure delivery, please add newsletter@bisnow.com to your address book, learn how
May 22, 2014
Behind the Deal: OslerBrook Sold
It's been tough getting into the golf spirit (although Weir-sy, below, certainly helped with his second overall finish Sunday at the Byron Nelson), with a long winter and months hearing phrases like "polar vortex." When talking CRE, the news that OslerBrook Golf & Country Club has been sold is like a straight-line tee shot down the first fairway.
Colliers associate VP John Reid tells us the private club had been in receivership. So this was one situation where the late winter conditions worked to everyone's advantage. Colliers won the right to list the property in January, then they had to market it, and shortlist interested parties up to a bidding process. Members of the club were naturally getting a little antsy—"am I going to pay my dues, and will all this get completed by the start of golf season?" (Also "did my work in the gym and the basement fix my slice.") And how is the course being cared for, with all the uncertainty and crappy weather (all you need to do is drive out to many of the area courses and see the condition of the greens to understand their general antsy-ness).
In the end it all got done. Colliers has a dedicated team of four based in Las Vegas (Colliers Golf Course Advisory Services Group, led by the group's US national director Keith Cubba) that does nothing but represent vendors in golf club deals, and John handles Canada for the group. The buyer was a group led by Bill MacWilliam of St. Andrew's Golf. Details were not released but it's in the “millions” John says. In the past 14 months the group has sold 18 golf courses in North America. This was their first foray outside the US. Studies have showed a decline in interest in the game across Canada. (How many clubs can you snap over your knee before you call it a day?) There are “too many holes in the ground” in some markets, John says, so expect more transactions on this front.
Elmo Back On The Market
“It Ain't Over Til It's Over,” Lenny Kravitz once sang. That's the case for Royal LePage Commercial's Neil Warshafsky. (Few people realize that Lenny Kravitz was singing about real estate.) He thought he had a deal done for Toronto's iconic El Mocambo on Spadina—that would have kept it a music club—but in the end the buyer couldn't firm up the financing. List price is $3.95M and “all options are open” in terms of redevelopment are on the table, Neil tells us—11k SF of space, plus a third floor open deck. Additional density is permitted under the zoning of the property, opening the door to a gym, boutique hotel, restaurant, even student residences (close to U of T).
What The Target Shakeup Means
The news that Target Canada president Tony Fisher has been ousted certainly adds to the storyline of doom. But one analyst points out the reverse of such a move, which makes it clear that Target is not exiting Canada, “putting to rest that crazy notion,” CIBC World Markets Corp retail analyst Perry Caicco tells us. Expect more aggressive pricing in the second half of 2014, Perry says, because the new company prez is a merchant, and pricing has been identified as a problem. The company also plans to name a non-executive chairman in Canada, who Perry expects to be a big name Canadian. (Is Wayne Gretzky available?)
And he anticipates a focus away from capital investment and further expansion of stores. As for that new Target Canada president, it's Mark Schindele, who was previously SVP of merchandising operations at Target Corp. That other non-executive chairman role will offer "counsel and support to the president" to ensure all strategies and tactics align with the Canadian marketplace, the company said in a statement. The company reported a $1B operating loss the first year up here, as it has aggressively opened 127 stores, with more scheduled to follow. The company yesterday reported a surge in sales in Canada in the first quarter (the colder winter months were a killer, although April was stronger) but an operating loss for Q1 of $211M, up from $205M a year earlier. Sales jumped to $393M from $86M a year earlier, keeping in mind they only had 24 stores open during the same period a year ago.
AY Adds Outlet Centre Specialists
With outlet centres now one of the hottest sectors of commercial real estate in Canada, Avison Young has added two specialists in the area—Lisa Quier Wagner and David Hinkle—to their team as principals, to focus on outlet centre strategic direction, marketing and management, as well as providing leading guidance and tenant advisory expertise. In an interview with Bisnow, Lisa and David—with a combined 50 years of commercial real estate experience—both acknowledged the growth potential for more outlet centres in the GTA. (Shopping is the new national sport.) Last week, Ivanhoe Cambridge opened the new, 520k SF Outlet Collection in Niagara Falls, hot on the heels of the Simon Property Group's Toronto Premium Outlets just west of Toronto.
Lisa and David most recently served as partners of the US-based Outlet Resource Group, a specialty retail consultancy firm, which they co-owned and co-founded. Both say through the years they have acquired extensive knowledge of how the outlet industry has evolved in Canada, having worked on outlet projects in Windsor and Kingston, to the point now where the industry is “really starting its maturation process,” Lisa says. “I wouldn't want to say where [the growth potential in the GTA is] because there are too many developers looking at the area and I don't want to tip our hand.”
Calling All Reporters
We're looking for the Bisnow face of Canada (and it doesn't have to be as beautiful as Ryan Gosling's or Rachel McAdams'). We're in need of a Vancouver/Toronto commercial real estate reporter, with a strong journalism background and a passion for writing. You have the gift for delivering groundbreaking real estate news in our breezy but super-informative manner. You live to break stories, work a beat, travel, uncover market trends, and rub elbows with the most powerful people in the industry. Send your journalism-oriented resume to: matt.black@bisnow.com.
For all the golfers out there: “I call upon all nations to do everything they can to stop these terrorist killers. Thank you. Now watch this drive.” – George W. Bush. Email mark.keast@bisnow.com